Want To Start Fly Fishing For Trout? Step 1: Forget (Almost) Everything You've Heard.

Want To Start Fly Fishing For Trout? Step 1: Forget (Almost) Everything You've Heard.

March 19, 2019 1 Comment

by Danny P. | @d.pusifer

For most of us, thinking back to our first catches will conjure memories of panfish or a similarly gullible warm-water resident. I'm no different, and I can vividly recall my first bluegill. Quickly though, a hierarchy was established between my beloved gills and largemouths. The smaller ones were great, but if you wanted cred the bigmouths were the way to go. And that’s what I did for the next decade or so. It was a lot of fun, and I'll never lose appreciation for what I learned about fishing heavy structure, especially docks.  

As many as 6 months of the year it was either inhospitable or illegal to do what I loved. Then, one year in December, the light bulb turned on: People catch trout year round. Looking back, it was an important epiphany. 

On hot, sunny days, high-quality fish could usually be found lurking in the darkness. Year in and out, this is how it went. From the spring opener until some point in October, you could find me picking apart shallow cover. However, for all the fun it was, time was limited. As many as 6 months of the year it was either inhospitable or illegal to do what I loved. Then, one year in December, the light bulb turned on: People catch trout year round. Looking back, it was an important epiphany. 

I took what I knew, researched as much as I could, and found myself in a fly shop for the first time. I made my way to the flies and did my best to relate. The first tray was full of streamers. Streamers can look like fuzzy soft plastics. I knew soft plastics. With a few pieces of advice from the sales associates, I was on my way.

Luckily, there was a pretty solid warm spell in mid January and I made the most of it. I wouldn’t say I was casting, but I was able to get my fly in the water. Looking around, the water looked familiar. I didn’t have a ton of experience with moving water, but the still water behind rocks, logs, and eddies was familiar enough that I could make it work. I’m not sure how it happened, but somehow I managed to connect and land my first brown on the fly. This was key, because if I could catch one by fluke, I could catch more on purpose.

We’ve all seen images from out West with anglers throwing dries in front of 50-foot casts. The few times I had previously targeted trout, this is what I did ... and it sucked.

As winter turned to spring, and spring to summer, I didn’t so much improve as simply revert to what I knew best. We’ve all seen images from out West with anglers throwing dries in front of 50-foot casts. The few times I had previously targeted trout, this is what I did ... and it sucked. The more I’m on the water, the more I realize this isn’t how it has to be. I believe these misconceptions keep a lot of people from realizing how fun and rewarding fly fishing can be.   

To quickly summarize my most important realizations about fly fishing:

  • You can fly fish just fine and never tie on a dry fly.
  • You can fly fish just fine and never know the Latin name for the bug you just discovered.
  • You can fly fish just fine and NEVER make a cast with more than 20 feet of fly line. (Tenkara rods are basically just a rod with a leader—completely eliminating the need for line.
  • Trout are majestic. They are gorgeous. And they are fish. Sometimes they’re extra wily, but all fish can leave you scratching your head wondering what went wrong. That’s part of the appeal.
  • And finally, if you’re confident in catching any species on artificials (except maybe catfish—this might not adapt so well to them), you can apply that knowledge to catching trout on flies.

Of course, there are differences among species, and I can’t claim you’ll be an excellent fly fisherman right out the gate, but with time you’ll start to see the little changes that will help bring fish to the net.

WARM UP TO WINTER TROUT FISHING
Here in the Wisconsin Driftless, the inland catch-and release-season opens in early January. Generally it’s pretty cold. The advantage is all the grasses and low-lying brush die off. Even before the first snow, there’s unprecedented access. It’s remarkably common to walk miles along secluded streams and hear nothing human-related for hours at a time. Until mid May, when you can practically see the grass growing, waders are often completely optional—especially when you fish on land easements or state-owned property.

Always map out your trip ahead of time. This helps to prevent finding a surprise tributary halfway to where you wanted to go, and keep a backup plan available just in case. More often than not, places you think wouldn’t fish well are at their best when you least expect it. During the last 5 years or so we've witnessed unprecedented and lasting warm snaps. Winter fishing doesn’t mean being unbearably uncomfortable, and when the sun is shining like it’s being focused through a magnifying glass, it’s not unusual to leave an extra layer in the vehicle. 

There are plenty of indoor activities during the cold months, but really ... what’s better than a tight line?



1 Response

Mike Young
Mike Young

April 18, 2019

Great article. I have the equipment, just needed the incentive. Your article may have just given me that.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The Trout Lab

Fly Fishing For North Shore Small-Stream Brookies | THE DRIP [Ep. 5]
Fly Fishing For North Shore Small-Stream Brookies | THE DRIP [Ep. 5]

September 26, 2019

Fall colors are blooming on the North Shore. We take a break from the brown trout, salmon, and steelhead runs to go after small-stream brook trout with our fly rods.

Read More

Point Up: Fly Fishing Tricks For Less Snags
Point Up: Fly Fishing Tricks For Less Snags

August 28, 2019

Relatively speaking, fish can go wherever they please. The spot they held in for the last three trips might be barren on the fourth. The creek that never produces could suddenly produce a dozen fish on an afterthought of a trip. Conditions can’t be controlled, but presentations can.

Read More

Going Rogue For Western Trout | THE DRIP [Ep. 4]
Going Rogue For Western Trout | THE DRIP [Ep. 4]

August 28, 2019

We venture thousands of miles outside the Driftless Area in this special episode of THE DRIP. It’s an epic fly-fishing road trip that leads us through the Black Hills streams of South Dakota to our primary destination: the legendary Rogue River, where we get hooked up with feisty steelheads through a combination of drift boat and DIY shore fishing.

Read More

THE TROUT LAB NEWSLETTER

Sign up now to get an exclusive discount and regular updates from Skinny Trout.